It was medical negligence that drove Ray Gosling to kill lover. Once can understand his desperation. But the doctor who said the pain was uncontrollable should be severely disciplined. If a doctor does not know how to stop someone's pain, he should not wash his hands of the situation, but ask a colleague who does know. The doctor in a pain clinic or a local hospice could have advised what to do.

Dr Richard Lamerton
16 February 2010

Mrs Ann Farmer commented today on the conditional discharge in the case of a mother, Mrs Kay Gilderdale, who assisted her daughter's death:

"As a sufferer from ME for eight years, I can understand the late Lynn Gilderdale feeling suicidal, especially in view of the severity of her symptoms. ME is a poorly understood condition, but only research into it is paid for by charities representing the sufferers. It is a condition that leaves the sufferer weak and exhausted, but despite this we are forced to fight for help.

read more

Life and Death Matters: Disability Rights and Incapacity Date: Monday 29 March 2010

Barristers and solicitors are entitled to claim 6 CPD points for attendance.

Further details:

Dr Jacqueline Laing: Tel: 0207 320 4930
Email:

Applications:

Claire Keefe: Tel: 0207 320 4950
Email:

Further Information:

Booking Form
Conference Flyer

Statement by ALERT Against Euthanasia

GOVERNMENT END OF LIFE CARE STRATEGY

Open to misinterpretation?

From reliable evidence, including official enquiries, it seems that some hospitals and care homes sometimes get things wrong where the elderly are concerned. The government's new "Quality Markers" have been sent out for consultation. Could they be misinterpreted, perhaps by staff influenced by the new official spokesman for the elderly, Joan Bakewell, who thinks that there are too many of them?

read more

Commenting on Baroness Warnock's latest proposal, a spokesman for ALERT said today (Friday 19th September):

"Baroness Warnock will make life worse for people with dementia.  She is encouraging them to see themselves as useless eaters, and to seek death in order to benefit society.

"Should her policy be put into action, there would be a moral hazard for NHS workers.  They would have an incentive to let people with dementia feel miserable and helpless, rather than helping them, because that would encourage suicide requests and so free up beds."

read more

It seems compassionate to support a woman dying of a progressive illness who doesn't want to leave it too late to commit suicide. In fact, it is compassionate to no-one but ourselves to promote her death instead of the good care which helpless people deserve. We are not really doing ourselves a kindness, either, by deciding that a human life has no value. If Debbie Purdy, and others like her, can be put on the list of people society can do without, so can we all.

In a statement today, Elspeth Chowdharay-Best, Hon. Secretary of Alert said:

"'Dignity in Dying' (formerly the Voluntary Euthanasia Society) has sent out advice with their new Advance Decision by which signatories refuse 'treatment' in hospital if they should lose capacity.

"They say correctly that in order to ensure that an existing Living Will is binding under the Mental Capacity Act 'you must write the following statement in the section referring to the refusal of life-sustaining treatment: The decisions set out in my living will apply, even if my life is at risk as a result.'

read more

Where are we going?

The General Medical Council yesterday condoned the actions of a consultant neonatologist, Dr Michael Munro, in giving a drug to stop the breathing of two sick babies who refused to die.

Elspeth Chowdharay-Best, Secretary of ALERT, commented today: "We know from the history of the last century that highly civilised countries can turn to barbarism in a short space of time. In Nazi Germany the descent was led by the medical profession.
"The General Medical Council seems to have decided, like the Nazi doctors, that disabled babies have no right to live. We need to look harder at where we are going."

read more

By Richard Lamerton
Hospice of the Valleys
Tredegar, Wales

In Switzerland, if a person of sound mind requests help to commit suicide because they have an incurable physical illness, it is legal to kill them. Now the Swiss Federal Court has decided that someone with a mental illness can make a similar demand.

There are no safeguards or concerns for vulnerable people who may be pressurised to get out of the way. The person must only be able to make their own decision. A psychiatrist's opinion that the condition is incurable is enough.

One the killing of ill or depressed people becomes normal, the door is open for a culture which makes them feel they should not be a burden. That it is only decent to ask to be eliminated. An obligation to die will arise, and eventually it will be imposed on the weak and vulnerable and those who are perceived as being too stupid to recognise that their life is not worth living.

read more

The BBC assert that "most support voluntary euthanasia" based upon results from the British Social Attitudes Survey.

In response Dr Peter Saunders, campaign director of the Care Not Killing Alliance, said: "This opinion poll, which purports to show that a large majority of people would favour a change in the law to allow euthanasia, is misleading as it has been based on reflex answers to a yes/no question.

read more